Connect with us

Hi, what are you looking for?


Clean Power

Anatomy Of A Watershed Event

For background, please see this previous article: “Will A Watershed Event Turn The Tide Against Fossil Fuels?”

A watershed event is defined as: An event or period that is important because it represents a big change and the start of new developments.

For background, please see this previous article: “Will A Watershed Event Turn The Tide Against Fossil Fuels?

A watershed event is defined as: An event or period that is important because it represents a big change and the start of new developments.

Watershed events seem to change the landscape overnight, but they typically don’t come out of nowhere. They typically come along when the background is already quietly laid, often under the surface but to a point where the public is ready to accept a sudden change in direction. When they happen, it’s as if one has gone through a door and locked it behind them.

That said, sometimes watershed events are hard to pinpoint except in retrospect. We may not be able to point to a single event that leads to us getting serious against climate change, but then again, the future is not yet written and it is very possible that a change in motivation will suddenly arrive. If a Green New Deal is put into law and the USA starts decarbonizing rapidly, everyone else will likely follow suit. If the climate lawsuits prevail and force oil companies to pay reparations, then the tide may rapidly turn as they did when cigarette companies suddenly found themselves having to pay monetary damages.

There are perhaps infinite possibilities and which one will change the future for the better is anybody’s guess.

Let’s imagine Tesla came along in 1972. Virtually no one would have bought its EVs — the range would have been terrible with the deep-cycle lead-acid batteries of the time (there were no lithium-ion batteries yet), the number of cycles till battery replacement would have been dismal, and gasoline was abundant, cheap, and the supply seemed to be endless.

Just a year later, the oil crisis came along, along with economic peril, oil rationing, fear of future oil shortages, and huge price spikes. Tesla may have survived if it was founded at this time, but the economics of EVs were still not there and the batteries/range were still poor. Once things settled, the status quo would have continued unabated and Tesla would have probably gone out of business. Even the 1979 repeat was transient and would not have saved EVs.

Fast forward a few decades to 2008. Oil prices spiked and once again talk of alternatives rose. Squeaky wheels getting the grease. Tesla was practically unknown at this point, probably not having even produced a dozen cars yet when oil prices spiked to $147/barrel in July 2008. Hence, Tesla was not yet ready to bring us the EV revolution.

The Roadster, Model S, and Model X did come along and sold well in their segments (having the benefit of lithium batteries) but remained non-mainstream vehicles, because of their purchase prices and the company’s production constraints. But they got people talking. The ultimate goal (Master Plan) was the mass-market Model 3. This car has sold incredibly well, and it is currently production constrained, yet has achieved incredible feats (in Norway, the Netherlands, etc.). But legacy automakers have been reluctant to commit to EVs and have spent the last decade plus fighting them. Sacrificial lambs aside (Volt, Bolt) no legacy player has yet stopped selling its ICE (internal combustion engine) vehicles. To retire ICE was sacrilege until very recently. Finally, the dam is breaking. Thanks to Tesla pressure, climate change, and the economics of EVs now being far more compelling than ICE vehicles, automakers are finally starting to take EVs seriously as the future of transportation. This will eventually lead to a domino event in which ICE vehicles are rapidly retired, but when and how has not yet been written.

In a separate yet related vein, building efficiency (insulation, energy usage) was also a low priority pre-oil crisis and the shock led to research and development, from superinsulation vs mass/glass to LEED to Net Zero, and eventually to Net Zero mandates in California, which are likely to spread in time. The squeaky wheel once again getting the grease and the background had again set the stage to acquire the basic engineering knowledge we take for granted today.

Ditto for Energy Star efficiency standards, which in a generation have saved hundreds of billions of dollars of energy and carbon. And to transition away from fossils, we have developed solar/wind/battery technology to be reliable and durable enough for grid-level use.

At this point, the technical stars have mostly aligned for large-scale renewable energy adoption.

Cost effective solar/wind Check
Costs less then building new fossil fuel/nuclear plants Check
Costs less then fuel for existing fossil/nuclear plants
Many Cases Check
Grid scale energy (battery) storage Check
Modeled proof that renewables can replace fossil energy Check
Annual production of solar/wind/batteries scaled to future demand growth Not Yet
Annual production of electric vehicles scaled to future demand growth Not Yet

Motivational facets

Media correctly covering the scope of the problem Not Yet
Voters electing climate change fighting leaders Not Yet
Plans made for rapid renewable deployment Not Yet
Funding mechanisms in place to scale production rapidly Not Yet
Subsidies, taxes and policy changes favouring renewables over fossil fuels Not Yet
Comprehensive renewable global deployment plan
Not Even Close

It’s very clear where we need to go from here. The technology is already developed and only needs scaling, the motivation is what is lacking. However, it is difficult to get the votes to fight climate change because voters often respond to single issues, smears, lies, reality denial, and easy answers. Interestingly, there is a solid majority who accept the reality of climate change, but enough vote for “more important” nonsense because it matters more to them than their own long-term survival. Climate change competes with the “need” for hate and loses.

In addition, humans often also have trouble seeing far ahead. More than the immediate future often gains little traction. For example, few save for retirement.

In conclusion, from Greta Thunberg to Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez to Jane Fonda, the fight for rising to the challenge of defeating climate change is just heating up. But what will be the straw that breaks the camel’s back? A major climate change–induced natural disaster that turns the tide (pun intended), voters turning elections, divestment, dollar voting, or something else?

Whatever it may be, we need to find a way to accelerate its arrival and get a comprehensive plan of action into place on time and completed on schedule.

As a final note, watershed events also happen in reverse. The election of Donald Trump did not come out of nowhere. From the Southern strategy in the 1960s to gerrymandering to Newt Gingrich’s obstructionism to Moscow Mitch McConnell’s scorched earth tactics to Trump running on hate and lies with an assist from the Electoral College, we have ended up in this cesspool. We have a lot of work to do to undo the damage being done by conservatives who know they are fading from obscurity but refuse to go without playing dirty (voter disenfranchisement, stacking courts).

So, in addition to runaway climate change, we are also facing a social progress turning point — as a society we have to decide if we want to revert to sophistry, hate, and violence, or whether we wish to move on to ethics and renewable energy.

Now that we are in complete chaos, an opportunity has been created to get some rapid progress accomplished. We must strike while the iron is hot, seizing the opportunity to go from fossil fuel shills in government positions to fossil retirements and renewables installed at breakneck speed. It also would not hurt if we decided to manufacture our own renewable equipment so that we can create employment to replace lost fossil fuel jobs.

Sign up for daily news updates from CleanTechnica on email. Or follow us on Google News!

Have a tip for CleanTechnica, want to advertise, or want to suggest a guest for our CleanTech Talk podcast? Contact us here.

Former Tesla Battery Expert Leading Lyten Into New Lithium-Sulfur Battery Era — Podcast:

I don't like paywalls. You don't like paywalls. Who likes paywalls? Here at CleanTechnica, we implemented a limited paywall for a while, but it always felt wrong — and it was always tough to decide what we should put behind there. In theory, your most exclusive and best content goes behind a paywall. But then fewer people read it! We just don't like paywalls, and so we've decided to ditch ours. Unfortunately, the media business is still a tough, cut-throat business with tiny margins. It's a never-ending Olympic challenge to stay above water or even perhaps — gasp — grow. So ...
If you like what we do and want to support us, please chip in a bit monthly via PayPal or Patreon to help our team do what we do! Thank you!
Written By

I've had an interest in renewable energy and EVs since the days of deep cycle lead acid conversions and repurposed drive motors (and $10/watt solar panels). How things have changed. Also I have an interest in systems thinking (or first principles as some call it), digging into how things work from the ground up. Did you know that 97% of all Wikipedia articles link to Philosophy? A very small percentage link to Pragmatism. And in order to put my money where my mouth is I own one (3x split) Tesla share.   A link to all my articles


You May Also Like

Climate Change

A new report has found that Google is breaking its October 2021 promise to not sell ads on YouTube videos containing climate misinformation. The...

Climate Change

Climate-themed board games are growing in popularity. Their designers hope they can spark action. Europe is planting trees to offset its emissions but is...

Climate Change

Climate change is about extremes and adapting to those extremes. Brisbane experienced a 10-year drought from 2001 to 2011. During that time, washing your...

Climate Change

Researchers used artificial intelligence and machine learning to analyze more than 4 billion geolocated tweets over six years and found that, of the tweets...

Copyright © 2023 CleanTechnica. The content produced by this site is for entertainment purposes only. Opinions and comments published on this site may not be sanctioned by and do not necessarily represent the views of CleanTechnica, its owners, sponsors, affiliates, or subsidiaries.