Connect with us

Hi, what are you looking for?

Images courtesy of Volkswagen and Tesla.


Wall Street Journal: Tesla Model Y vs. Volkswagen ID.4

Originally published on EV Annex.

While Tesla has been a trailblazer in the electric vehicle space, legacy car companies have been laggards to date. That’s about to change. One automaker everyone is hoping lives up to its promises is Volkswagen. And according to some observers, the German automaker’s all-electric ID.4 SUV could be a real threat to Tesla’s Model Y. Wall Street Journal auto columnist Dan Neil recently weighed in on the showdown.

After driving VW’s ID.4, Neil says, “Compared to this light-footed, sweet-singing creature, gas-burning competitors feel like puttering, muttering nincompoops.” Good to hear — it would be great to see the ID.4 replace a few gasmobiles out there. But can it take away sales from Tesla?

Ummm, not so much. “So when I say the ID.4 is five years behind the comparable Tesla, it’s not because I’m an Elon fanboy, a VW hater, or that I have anything to gain or lose personally. That is my best guess, based on my weeklong test drive of VW’s hot-from-the-oven, slightly underbaked strudel,” writes Neil.

That said, from a looks standpoint, Neil gives the nod to the ID.4. “With its sloe-eyed canopy and high-cut hips, optional LED-illuminated nose and 20-inch alloy Spirographs, the ID.4 is not without curb appeal,” he says. And, “the ID.4 can afford the luxury of a full-length glass roof. It’s pretty spectacular.”

The tech, however, is another story. According to Neil, the VW ID.4’s “12-inch center touch screen takes ages to boot up and can lag behind user inputs. It’s not very pretty, either. The ‘Car-Net’ phone app — a Tesla-like remote interface with the car, accessing charging and climate functions — failed to talk to the car when I tried it several times.”

On the other hand, Neil observes, “Tesla’s displays respond at the speed of thought and their mobile IT is coded by the fiery finger of God.”

Okay, so what about interior space? “With the rear seat backs folded, the cargo space measures 64.2 cubic feet, comparable to a Tesla Model Y. But, surprisingly, unlike the Y … the ID.4 has no front trunk.” Neil also notes, “There is a lot of wasted space in the package around and below the roof (the ‘A’) pillars” inside the ID.4.

When it comes to the ID.4’s sub-par range and acceleration numbers, the vehicle’s weight just might play a role. Neil points out “ID.4’s less-than-optimized curb weight: 4,600 pounds. That is quite a lot, some 200 pounds heavier than a Model Y with two motors. I infer from the ID.4’s anvil-like density that the team ran out of time. Development engineers always say cutting mass is the hardest part.”


Appreciate CleanTechnica’s originality? Consider becoming a CleanTechnica Member, Supporter, Technician, or Ambassador — or a patron on Patreon.
Have a tip for CleanTechnica, want to advertise, or want to suggest a guest for our CleanTech Talk podcast? Contact us here.

Written By

Matt is all about Tesla. He’s a TSLA investor, and he loves driving the family's Model 3, Model S, and Model X company cars. As co-founder of EVANNEX, a family business specializing in aftermarket Tesla accessories, he’s served as a contributor/editor of Electric Vehicle University (EVU) and the Owning Model S and Getting Ready for Model 3 books. He writes daily about Tesla and you can follow his work on the EVANNEX blog.


You May Also Like

Clean Transport

Want a Tesla Semi? Now you can order one if you have $25,000 available.


Malaysian Prime Minister Ismail Sabri Yaakob wants Tesla to open a plant in Malaysia. He recently invited several Fortune 500 companies, especially Tesla, to...


Tesla’s move into India is currently on hold, Reuters reports, adding that Tesla has abandoned a search for a showroom space while reassigning some...


Tesla CEO Elon Musk shared some thoughts in a recent interview with Financial Times on Tesla’s aspiration to reach the goal of 20 million...

Copyright © 2021 CleanTechnica. The content produced by this site is for entertainment purposes only. Opinions and comments published on this site may not be sanctioned by and do not necessarily represent the views of CleanTechnica, its owners, sponsors, affiliates, or subsidiaries.