Connect with us

Hi, what are you looking for?


Carbon Pricing

Danish Climate Council Recommendations Hard To Swallow — Well, Of Course They Are

On March 9th, the Danish Climate Council presented a number of recommendations aimed at achieving Denmark’s 70% reduction of greenhouse gases by 2030. The transition requires both rapid implementations of known clean technologies as well as a long-term strategic effort. Is it going to be hard? Of course it is! Do we have to do it? Of course we do!

On March 9th, the Danish Climate Council presented a number of recommendations aimed at achieving Denmark’s 70% reduction of greenhouse gases by 2030. The transition requires both rapid implementations of known clean technologies as well as a long-term strategic effort. Is it going to be hard? Of course it is! Do we have to do it? Of course we do!

The Corona Timeout

Two days after the report was released everybody stopped talking about it, because Denmark was effectively being shut down due to the spread of the Corona virus. All schools and institutions closed. All public servants were told to stay home. I had in fact just recovered from a severe flu and was ready to go back to work when I was told to stay home.

Any plans to pick up from the historic deal in December 2019 resulting in a Danish Climate Law will obviously be postponed, but that just gives us a bit more time to think about what this all means. We have to fight hard to minimize the impact of the Corona virus, yes, but we know it will be gone in a few months. Potentially civilization ending climate change will not go away unless we fight very hard to minimize the damage. Virus or no virus, mother nature just doesn’t care.

By the way, could a downturn in global fossil fuel use prompted by curtailments of travel and social gatherings in response to the spread of the Corona virus be seen in atmospheric carbon dioxide concentration? The Scripps Institution of Oceanography at UC San Diego, known for the Keeling Curve recording of CO2 levels, has an interesting take on this.

Known Roads & New Tracks

The broad majority in the Danish Parliament decided in December 2019 to enter into an agreement on a new climate law, meaning Denmark must have reduced its emissions of greenhouse gases by 70% in 2030 and be climate neutral by 2050. This has resulted the Danish Climate Council report by the name of “Known roads and new tracks to 70% reduction,” and it will be hard to swallow, because it contains drastic proposals.

It will require a significant effort to achieve a 70% reduction, and the transition will be felt in most parts of Danish society. The Climate Council’s report shows that the socio-economic costs of meeting the target will increase gradually over the next ten years, reaching DKK 15 — 20 billion ($2.2 — 3 billion) in the year 2030. This cost corresponds to less than 1% of GDP. Peter Møllgaard, chairman of the Climate Council says:

“We will not reach the 70% target by 2030 if we continue as we usually do. But if we put action behind the words and take action immediately, it is possible to achieve a 70% reduction without breaking the Danish economy. The Climate Council recommends that we quickly start implementing all the mitigation elements we already know — such as more electric cars, reduced soil cultivation and more biogas — but that we also start planning and develop the slightly more difficult adjustments that will bring us all the way to 70%.”

Implementation & Development

In the change towards 2030, the Climate Council distinguishes between two tracks: the implementation track and the development track.

Translated graph from the Climate Council report

The implementation track represents all the solutions and technologies we already know that need to be implemented to take that first step towards the 70% goal by 2030. This track achieves about a 60% reduction, which means, among other things, that all electricity and heat are to be produced by renewable sources. As a result coal will face total shutdown by 2025.

The development track represents the more unknown strategic change elements needed to reach the 70% target in 2030, and also to ensure that Denmark can reach the final goal of 2050 on climate neutrality. The track implies, among other things, that Denmark is developing a strategy for CO2 storage as soon as possible, as well as agriculture, transport and industry contributing to further reductions.

A General GHG Tax

Technological solutions or behavioral changes only come into effect when the right political tools are put into use. Therefore, the Climate Council presents a policy package in which a greenhouse gas tax is given a key role, but must be supplemented by a number of other instruments. The tax must reflect the principle of the polluter paying for the damage they do, and it must therefore be significantly more expensive to emit CO2 and other greenhouse gases. To reach the target of a 70% reduction in 2030, the Climate Council estimates that a GHG tax should be approx. DKK 1,500 ($223) per tonne by 2030. Peter Møllgaard elaborates:

“A general greenhouse gas tax is a key instrument in the Climate Council’s report, which will make it more expensive to emit CO2 and other greenhouse gases. Today, the Danish tax system is a bit of a mess, and we therefore believe that the system should be changed as soon as possible so that we get a uniform tax that has a significantly higher level than today. At the same time, we have to make sure that production does not just move to other countries, along with the pollution, but this can be handled with a so-called bottom deduction for competitive companies.”

I encourage you to read my explanation of the current Danish energy tax system, it doesn’t get more messy than that!

Translated graph from the Climate Council report showing total GHG emissions in Denmark since 1990

The policy package also contains a number of other initiatives such as investment in research and development, an expansion of the renewable energy from offshore wind farms, a reduction in the tax on electricity for heating, rolling out EV charging stations, taking out low-lying farmland, green public investment, and much more.

In 2025 We Pass The 50% Mark

The 70% target and the Danish commitments to the Paris Agreement can only be achieved if we implement the known solutions quickly. In this regard, the Danish Parliament has asked the Climate Council to make recommendations for an indicative target in 2025. In the report, the Climate Council indicates a target of 50 to 54% in 2025.

The Climate Council’s recommendations for the mitigation elements indicate a concrete way to achieve a 50% reduction in 2025. However, in order to follow a linear development towards the target in 2030, Denmark must have achieved a 54% reduction by 2025. This will require a significantly accelerated transition in the next few years and considerable political willingness to pay the price to reach 54%, because no current measures can reduce greenhouse gas emissions that much, and it will take time for new measures to have effect.

Immediate Package Spawns Immediate Resistance

The longer it takes for politicians to announce new framework conditions, the greater the risk that investments will be made that do not point towards the target in 2030. These are, for example, the choice of solutions in the heating sector. The Climate Council therefore also presents a package in the report that can be adopted immediately. Some cardinal points in the package is the hefty carbon tax and shift to electricity in the transport sector.

In the news on the day of the release of the report, the director of the Danish industry organization Kent Damsgaard expressed it this way: “We would advise against imposing a high tax such as the Climate Council proposes.”

Screenshot from the DR interview – Kent Damsgaard, director of the Danish Industry organization

Well, yes of course he opposes. He has to express the fear of Danish industry moving business abroad and the resulting loss of employment. But do we have a choice?

When Peter Møllgaard was asked what the Climate Council would do if its guidelines were not accepted by the government, he answered without hesitation: “If the government chooses not to follow our advice, then we must find other ways to reach the 70%.”

Screenshot from the DR interview – Peter Møllgaard, chairman Danish Climate Council

This is no time to point fingers and blame one another, as time is of the essence. However, there is no response from the government on this report yet, as it has a certain virus to deal with right now. When the Corona crisis is over, I expect we will witness tough negotiations, but I expect many of these recommendations being converted into law along with reassurance of the Danish industry to not worry about job losses. After all, there is a lot of work to be done.

Appreciate CleanTechnica’s originality and cleantech news coverage? Consider becoming a CleanTechnica Member, Supporter, Technician, or Ambassador — or a patron on Patreon.

Don't want to miss a cleantech story? Sign up for daily news updates from CleanTechnica on email. Or follow us on Google News!

Have a tip for CleanTechnica, want to advertise, or want to suggest a guest for our CleanTech Talk podcast? Contact us here.
Written By

Jesper had his perspective on the world expanded vastly after having attended primary school in rural Africa in the early 1980s. And while educated a computer programmer and laboratory technician, working with computers and lab-robots at the institute of forensic medicine in Aarhus, Denmark, he never forgets what life is like having nothing. Thus it became obvious for him that technological advancement is necessary for the prosperity of all humankind, sharing this one vessel we call planet earth. However, technology has to be smart, clean, sustainable, widely accessible, and democratic in order to change the world for the better. Writing about clean energy, electric transportation, energy poverty, and related issues, he gets the message through to anyone who wants to know better. Jesper is founder of and a long-term investor in Tesla, Ørsted, and Vestas.


You May Also Like

Clean Transport

Vikingbus, a Danish bus company, has ordered 31 Mercedes-Benz eCitaro all-electric vehicles. These are to be primarily operated in the municipality of Køge, a...

Clean Transport

Vattenfall, one of Europe’s largest producers and retailers of electricity and heat, has delivered 32 fast chargers to Tide Bus in Denmark’s fifth-largest city,...

Clean Power

Siemens Gamesa set a fresh record in wind generation this week. Specifically, a Siemens SG 14-222 DD offshore wind turbine prototype set the record....


The local news outlet TV2 Østjylland reports that at the Vestas headquarters in Aarhus, Denmark, the country’s largest grid battery has been deployed, and...

Copyright © 2022 CleanTechnica. The content produced by this site is for entertainment purposes only. Opinions and comments published on this site may not be sanctioned by and do not necessarily represent the views of CleanTechnica, its owners, sponsors, affiliates, or subsidiaries.