Connect with us

Hi, what are you looking for?

CleanTechnica
For years now, Tesla has enjoyed a market capitalization sufficient to distinguish it as one of America’s 500 most important publicly traded companies. The missing ingredient for Tesla’s inclusion in the granddaddy of all indexes, the Standard and Poor’s 500, has been consistent profitability. Now that Tesla has shown a profit of more than $300 million in Q3 of 2018 and its CEO Elon Musk predicts continued profitability ahead, inclusion in the S&P 500 index is extremely likely in the not-so-distant future. Let’s look at this event’s implications for Tesla and its stock price, plus consider the likely timing of such a move.

Clean Power

Tesla’s Upcoming Inclusion In The S&P 500 Index

For years now, Tesla has enjoyed a market capitalization sufficient to distinguish it as one of America’s 500 most important publicly traded companies. The missing ingredient for Tesla’s inclusion in the granddaddy of all indexes, the Standard and Poor’s 500, has been consistent profitability. Now that Tesla has shown a profit of more than $300 million in Q3 of 2018 and its CEO Elon Musk predicts continued profitability ahead, inclusion in the S&P 500 index is extremely likely in the not-so-distant future. Let’s look at this event’s implications for Tesla and its stock price, plus consider the likely timing of such a move.

For years now, Tesla has enjoyed a market capitalization sufficient to distinguish it as one of America’s 500 most important publicly traded companies. The missing ingredient for Tesla’s inclusion in the granddaddy of all indexes, the Standard and Poor’s 500, has been consistent profitability. Now that Tesla has shown a profit of more than $300 million in Q3 of 2018 and its CEO Elon Musk predicts continued profitability ahead, inclusion in the S&P 500 index is extremely likely in the not-so-distant future. Let’s look at this event’s implications for Tesla and its stock price, plus consider the likely timing of such a move.

When a company has been added to the S&P 500 index, that event marks a definitive move from a status of startup to arrival as one of the most significant businesses in the United States. Such a mark of distinction surely is not necessary with many inhabitants along the coasts and with young people in general. For them, the company already reigns as an aspirational brand. As for the majority of the country’s population who haven’t yet awakened to things Tesla, the legitimacy of S&P 500 inclusion can at least serve as a nudge towards acceptance.

The biggest effect upon Tesla from an S&P 500 inclusion will likely be seen in the form of stock price appreciation. For many companies, S&P 500 inclusion results in a modest bump upwards in stock value, something along the lines of 5%. This increase comes as funds that are indexed to the S&P 500 acquire shares of the new company in order to reproduce the index’s contents. As you would expect, that buying bids the stock price higher. In a recent instance of S&P 500 inclusion when Twitter was added to the index, we saw a nearly 5% jump in the stock price on the day inclusion was announced, and then over the next two weeks Twitter added of total of about 20% to its stock price. That’s not counting the likely considerable front-running of the S&P 500 announcement when it became clear to speculators that Twitter would likely be added to the index. Without a great deal of research, it’s difficult to isolate how much of the pre- and post-announcement climb was specifically due to inclusion in the S&P 500 index, but it’s likely quite a bit more than the one-day 5% rise from being added to the index.

Consider, too, the effect of more shares of TSLA being bought and then more-or-less permanently held by funds mimicking the S&P 500 index. These shares are not going to be reduced in numbers as a recession approaches or threatening news appears on the horizon (which can happen with holdings by typical institutional investors when they see the need to transition to a more bond-heavy mix of securities). The net effect would be one of added stability to the stock price during negative times. These shares held by the index funds reduce the availability of shares to buy, but demand for buying has not been reduced, and from a simple supply and demand standpoint, there will be added pressure for price appreciation as Tesla grows and the stock price inevitably rises with that growth.

As with Twitter, Tesla will likely gravitate toward the high end of stock price appreciation from inclusion in the index. Below is an explanation of why we come to that conclusion.

First, there’s the general volatility of Tesla’s stock (TSLA) to be considered. Next, figure in the effect on tens of millions of shares sold short, and finally consider the effect of TSLA’s very high ratio of outstanding option contracts compared to its number of shares.

A great contributor to the volatility of Tesla’s stock is the difficulty in assigning it a value. Tesla is presently growing at more than 50% per year, which makes determining a value on its present performance an exercise in gross underestimation. Thus, analysts figure theoretical profits that Tesla will be producing in a future year and then apply discounts to arrive at a present value of those future profits. Ask a short seller what Tesla will be worth a few years from now and a likely response would be “zero.” Ask a bullish investor, such as ARK Invest’s Catherine Wood, and you’ll receive an estimate as high as $4000 a share, depending upon whether Tesla is one of the first companies to achieve fully autonomous driving. That’s quite a range! Small changes in expectations through good or bad news can sway the public’s opinion greatly within this range, and so Tesla trading includes massive swings.

With short sellers holding more than 30 million shares of Tesla’s stock, there is typically a significant reaction when good news sends the stock price higher. In many stocks, shorts tend to enter positions when the stock is near a local high, when the stock price is most likely to be overvalued. They are then most likely to sell when the stock price is depressed and likely undervalued. This sell high/buy low strategy can be profitable and it adds a certain level of stability to the stock trading by buffering the climbing when the stock is heading too high too fast and providing a softer landing as the stock price approaches a likely bottom. Rather amazingly, Tesla shorts often do just the opposite. When TSLA is near a low and a new piece centered around fear, uncertainty, and doubt (FUD) comes out, new shorts pile into the stock, egged on by the “Tesla is a zero” mindset that suggests that the company is going to go bankrupt and you want to get in while there’s still some value left in the company. Inevitably, the stock price rises when the dire warnings fail to materialize and this new batch of short sellers takes a painful elevator ride upstairs until they either depart their positions on their own initiatives, are forced out through margin calls, or hold on with the hopes that a reversal is coming soon.

Tesla is presently at a price where any further increases yield additional margin calls for the shorts and higher numbers of shorts buying to close their positions, which reinforces more stock price increases and additional covering. Any sizeable positive catalyst to send the stock price higher only speeds up the processes of shorts buying to cover and that buying adding additional appreciation to the stock price. Inclusion in the S&P 500 index would definitely be such a catalyst.

Consider, too, the effect of huge numbers of outstanding options. While Tesla has about 172 million shares of stock issued, only about 127 million shares are actively traded (the float). Now, compare these 127 million shares with existing put and call options, which presently number more than 2 million contracts. Since each contract is for the equivalent of 100 shares, that’s the equivalent of more than 200 million shares of TSLA trading in options, a much higher number than the actual shares of Tesla being actively traded and a much higher percentage of options to shares than most other stocks. Tesla’s volatility is of course the reason why so many options are traded in its stock. These two types of securities, stocks and options, influence each other. The stock price movements determine which options win and which lose, naturally, but the system works the other way around, too. When Tesla’s stock moves higher, the brokerage houses that sold Tesla options hedge their bets by buying shares of TSLA in a process known as delta hedging. Thus, any rise in the stock price typically begets more rise as the delta hedging keeps the option sellers from exposing themselves to unnecessary risk.

Combine these three factors and you have an extremely volatile mixture. The lack of a clearly defined TSLA valuation sets the stage for great volatility.

When the stock price goes up, its upward movement is accentuated not only by short sellers buying shares to cover their positions, but also by the delta-hedge buying by the sellers of options. Each factor reinforces rather than opposes the movement of the other and you have what can be called a dynamically unstable situation.

Of course, all these factors work together in precisely the opposite direction when the stock price is heading downward, which is why a catalyst such as FUD can be so powerful for depressing the stock price. If you take a look at Tesla stock’s trading in 2018, you will see the stock routinely bouncing like a ping pong ball from one natural top (the upper Bollinger band) down to one natural bottom (the lower Bollinger band) and then repeating itself with these massive price swings.

The problem with short sellers just waiting for the next down cycle to cover is that a fundamental change has just occurred at Tesla: the company has entered what may well be a period of prolonged and persistent profitability. With such a fundamental change in character, many experienced traders expect the stock price to break out and rise above the recent trading ranges and establish itself as a company with a significantly higher priced stock. In other words, that expected reversal might not happen as the stock instead heads higher, possibly much higher.

If there are no big surprises in Tesla’s future, the timing for Tesla’s S&P 500 inclusion date can be roughly estimated as follows: The Standard and Poor’s 500 index looks for a net profit in a company’s most recent 4 quarters. Tesla’s losses in Q1 and Q2 of 2018 were significant enough that they are not likely to be cancelled out with Q3 and Q4 profits. Instead, it will be the Q1 2019 performance that will likely qualify Tesla for the index because one unprofitable quarter from 2018 will be dropped (Q1) and replaced with a more favorable quarter (Q1 of 2019) in the calculations. Thus, the math looks excellent for S&P 500 inclusion after the results of Q1 2019 are released in late April or early May.

Once those numbers are present, the S&P 500 decision-makers may take some time to determine which company will be exiting the index, but once that task is completed, we should hear of Tesla being included in the index. The market is forward looking, and you can expect some funds to be picking up TSLA early in order to avoid the higher cost of acquiring the stock right after the announcement, and of course speculators will do the same.

Tesla’s inclusion in the Standard & Poor’s 500 index during the first half of 2019 will only add to a growing list of the company’s accomplishments. Model 3 should have achieved a stable production rate at a noticeably higher number by that time, Model Y should be revealed, the significantly faster hardware for Tesla’s autopilot suite will be coming online, and we’ll see substantial progress with the Shanghai Gigafactory by then. All in all, the middle of 2019 should be an exciting time for Tesla owners and investors.

 
Appreciate CleanTechnica’s originality? Consider becoming a CleanTechnica Member, Supporter, Technician, or Ambassador — or a patron on Patreon.
 
 

Advertisement
 
Have a tip for CleanTechnica, want to advertise, or want to suggest a guest for our CleanTech Talk podcast? Contact us here.

Peter is a writer and innovator who began buying Tesla’s stock at $28 a share and has never looked back. This former airline pilot and college professor has a passion for applying new technologies to education. More recently, he has focused on understanding the trajectory of today’s clean energy revolution. He drives a Tesla and powers 100% of his house and vehicle’s energy needs through rooftop solar panels.

Comments

You May Also Like

Cars

We’ve had our Tesla Model 3 SR+ for a bit more than 2 years now. I recently had a service visit for a couple...

Cars

Volkswagen CEO Herbert Diess shared on Twitter that both Tesla’s CEO, Elon Musk, and INSEAD Professor Erin Meyer were in attendance at a Volkswagen...

Cars

Tesla has officially launched its insurance platform in Texas and has a neat way of determining how Tesla owners receive their rates. The insurance...

Cars

The Tesla Model Y outsold the Model 3 in China in September.

Copyright © 2021 CleanTechnica. The content produced by this site is for entertainment purposes only. Opinions and comments published on this site may not be sanctioned by and do not necessarily represent the views of CleanTechnica, its owners, sponsors, affiliates, or subsidiaries.