How Can India Accelerate Its Rooftop Solar Deployment?
By Akhilesh Magal
India’s solar market has grown exponentially in the last five years (see graph below). However, unlike most international markets, large ground-mounted grid-connected plants have driven India’s solar market, as opposed to rooftop systems. This difference in development made sense some time ago, when electricity prices were low and solar prices were higher. There was simply not enough incentive for consumers to shift to solar. This meant that the government had to create and promote the market through subsidies.
The government preferred to push large-scale plants simply because of economies of scale and the potential for cost reduction in solar tariffs. This has worked. Solar tariffs have fallen to incredible (and sometimes unsustainable) lows in the market. The recent bids in January 2016 saw record low tariffs of INR 4.34/kWh. This is now lower than most modern coal-fired power plants.
Having achieved the goal of rapidly bringing down solar tariffs (which was aptly aided by China’s manufacturing boom), the government now wants to accelerate rooftop solar systems. The Indian government has set a target of 40,000 MW of rooftop solar systems by 2022. Rooftop solar systems make sense because they are distributed by nature. They do not require expensive land. Also, the effect of geographically distributing the systems helps minimize variations. Further, the deployment of rooftop solar systems creates jobs.
The government has historically subsidized the rooftop solar market. It provided a subsidy of 30% to all rooftop consumers. Despite such an attractive subsidy, the market has simply not grown fast enough. As per estimates from MNRE, the rooftop solar installed capacity in India stood at 313 MW as of March 2016. Other analysts estimate this number to be higher at 525 MW. This difference can be explained due to the fact that the MNRE reports only those systems that have been supported by a subsidy. The significant difference in the numbers mean that most consumers are going ahead without availing themselves of the subsidy and perhaps even without informing the local distribution company.
The timely disbursement of subsidies has impeded the development of the market. Consumers have had to wait endlessly for the subsidies to arrive — sometimes in vain. Installers have sometimes taken the subsidy risk by discounting the system cost upfront. These installers have had to shut down because of cash-flow issues. The industry has on previous accounts called for the removal of the subsidy.
The government recognizes this issue and has aimed to allocate greater subsidies. The Cabinet Committee on Economic Affairs (CCEA) sanctioned INR 50 billion in January 2016, with the aim of clearing the bottlenecks. This is definitely one step in the right direction. The problem, however, may not lie in the quantity of subsidies, but rather in the disbursement mechanism.
Non-transparent approval procedures
Subsidies are channelized through SECI and other financial institutions. While this move prevents the abuse of subsidies, it also creates inordinate delays in the system. A better approach would be to transfer subsidies directly to the consumer’s bank account via an online transfer. This kind of subsidy transfer is not new to India. India has successfully implemented the LPG subsidy transfer in a similar manner. In this case, the government can verify the electricity meter number as registered with the local DISCOM. This will ensure that subsidies actually go to the consumers, as opposed to middlemen.
A potential solution
In fact, the entire approval process and subsidy channelization can happen online. A single online portal that links the consumer, the DISCOM, the Central Electrical Inspector (CEI) for safety approvals, and the state nodal agency, can help bring all the relevant stakeholders onto one common platform. This portal can be opened up to third party developers so that it can be automatically linked to a solar marketplace. Consumers should be allowed to pick the solar modules, inverters, and perhaps even structures online. Such a marketplace will bring transparency to the marketplace and bring down costs. It will also help establish user-driven reviews and ratings, by which the MNRE can disqualify system integrators or equipment manufacturers which receive several negative reviews.
The DISCOM barrier
Another key reason for the slow growth in the rooftop market is the DISCOM. Most DISCOMs in India are already cash-strapped (see complete list of DISCOM ratings here). DISCOMs are resistant to rooftop solar systems since they reduce their revenue. What is puzzling though, is that India has embarked on the world’s largest non-subsidized LED program. India has already distributed over 110 million LEDs through the UJALA scheme at the time of writing this article. The government estimates that nearly 3,000 MW of peak demand has been reduced because of this scheme. While the efforts of the government are laudable, the remarkable fact is that the government has gotten the DISCOM’s buy-in to this program, without which the program would have failed. Even power surplus states like Gujarat and Madhya Pradesh have signed up for the scheme. This goes to show that the implementation of such schemes needs a strong political push. It is time for the government to use similar channels of dialogue to get the rooftop solar market vibrant again.
A potential solution
Yes, the DISCOMs do stand to lose, and it could be detrimental to their financial health in the long run. This is where an incentive mechanism needs to be developed in order for DISCOMs to stay incentivized. One possible option is the Utility Owned Model. Under this model, DISCOMs (or one of their allied companies) own the solar plants on the rooftop of their clients and sign Power Purchase Agreements (PPA) with consumers. This way the DISCOMs retain their consumers for the lifetime of the solar power plant. The DISCOMs are best positioned to do this since they already own the grid, have the necessary technical expertise, have relevant networks with equipment suppliers and have the billing systems already set up. One significant barrier could be that DISCOMs are not allowed to get into the generation business. This is where they could act as a trader — sourcing solar power through developer-owned systems and reselling this to consumers who want to switch to solar. This would require advanced regulatory support such as virtual net metering, which is already being rolled out in states like Delhi.
Fixing three key aspects — an online and national wide uniform approval process, direct transfer of subsidy, and utilities participating in the rooftop boom — will ensure India’s moment in the rooftop sun. Judging by the political will and administrative action, at least in the power sector, these ideas do not seem far-fetched.
Akhilesh Magal is the Head Advisor – Solar Energy for the Gujarat Energy Research and Management Institute (GERMI), an institute dedicated to research in the fields of solar energy, energy efficiency, environment, and petroleum research. He is an environment engineer from Carnegie Mellon University and is an expert on solar policies and grid integration of renewable energy. He can reached at: akhilesh.m@germi.res.in
Have a tip for CleanTechnica? Want to advertise? Want to suggest a guest for our CleanTech Talk podcast? Contact us here.
CleanTechnica Holiday Wish Book
Our Latest EVObsession Video
CleanTechnica uses affiliate links. See our policy here.
A friend has a weekend retreat in the hills of Spain’s Costa Blanca but has no power. An obvious candidate for PV you would think but a previous attempt was thwarted by thieves who apparently cruise round remote properties removing anything possible. Could this be a factor in any poor remote regions?
In most poor remote regions homes are not weekend retreats, but residences. And often the house is never left unattended. Even if the entire family needs to leave for a wedding or funeral someone will be recruited to stay in the house and keep an eye on things.
Theft can always be a problem with an unoccupied house. Sometimes thieves break in and rip out copper wire and pipe.
I saw one picture of a village solar array that was installed on top of a very high pole, higher than could be reached with a normal “get on the roof” ladder. And the base was encircled with razor wire. Not likely anyone was going to steal those panels at night.
Another village was using solar lanterns which need to be out in the sunshine during the day. Something easy for a thief, curious child, or monkey to make off with. A villager created a job for himself. He traveled the village in the morning collecting lanterns, charged them in his fenced yard during the day, and returned them in the late afternoon.
I suppose a clever person could design a panel mount that made it difficult to remove the panels and thieves would bypass the array and go looking for an easier target. A tall metal pole would mean that the thieves would have to bring a long ladder with them and spend a lot of time unbolting the panels. Use machine bolts with theft resistant heads.
Maybe they could install cheap CCTV cameras and motion detectors and have a security guard attend the house as soon as there is a break-in.
I profit about six to eight thousand dollars a month from working online at home. So if you are looking to work simple computer-based work for 2h-5h /day from comfort of your home and get valuable profit for doing it… Then this gig is for you… SELF90.COM
Thanks, Bob, for your ideas although I suspect our friend, who has adopted the line of least resistance,avoiding further temptation by keeping nothing of value in or around the property and leaving it unlocked to reduce the risk of damage from break-ins.
Really, I posed the question, more, I admit, in hope than anticipation, to invite responses from the actual places affected. Be a test of CT’s penetration if nothing else.
OK, how about rigging up a small trailer containing the batteries, panels, and rest of the system. With room for the other stuff that isn’t safe to leave in the house when no one is there.
If parking where he lives is a problem or the distance great then find a place closeby where the trailer can be safely stored. And possibly plugged in so the batteries are charged when he picks it up.
Roll up, Pull out the panels and hang them off the trailer. Run a heavy extension cord from trailer to house.
Thanks, Bob, I’ll suggest that when I see him.
Most residences in India, at least in the cities, tend to be 4 floor apartments, with a flat roof on top that is ripe for solar installation. In the pre-cable days, these roofs used to boast satellite dishes and other electronics. It would be nearly impossible to scale 4 flights of stairs with solar panels strapped to your back. Safety is not the primary cause for the lack of adoption. The cost of panels may have dropped, but all the other electronics required still put the tech beyond the reach of your average middle class Indian.
My understanding is that some middle class families already have installed batteries to carry them through grid failures.
That means that they already have the inverter. Charge controllers for connecting panels to batteries are not expensive.
No need to climb four flights of stairs with panels. Climb up carrying a length of rope.
When people and other God’s creatures have little to no resources the obvious result is an all inclusive search for remedy. Locks help honest people remember self respect and honesty.
I might try offering readily accessible charging ports, with obvious signage … Neighbors may become protective/proactive. In any case, being a good neighbor and good will are respectable, personable qualities.
I would still use some or all of Bob’ ideas and add a little braising weld on each nut and bolt along with electrifying the panel frames with an electric pulse generator. A cattle fencing electric shock may piss someone off and in that case I wonder what will happen…
Peace thru Compassion and Education
Interesting article, thoughtful. I wonder about getting power out to where its needed desperately…, NOW! If its only to pump water and listen to radio or maybe read a book with a small fan etc.
India is a perfect market for a combined Tesla-Solar city. Governance and electricity networks are far from good. Roof-top solar combined with powerwalls will be very attractive for the reasonably well off.
The problem with rooftop solar plants are the technical knowledge, management and financial health of Discom. The roofs also generally support water tanks etc and meter rooms are generally in basements costing extra investment. The Government needs to develop roof top solar projects in SPV mode. This SPV can be RWA. The SPV may install roof top solar plants in its area with institutional finance and collect all powers at one source by creating grid over roofs and evacuate the power to local industry/railway or big consumers. The profit so earned can be distributed to roof top owners in the ratio of catchment area. After intial 5-6 years the investment will be recovered and SPV and roof top owners will get good returns.