Fossil Fuels new york times reports natural gas fracking might be bubble

Published on June 27th, 2011 | by Tina Casey


Financial Analysts Say Natural Gas Fracking Ain’t So Great – Wait, What?

June 27th, 2011 by  

new york times reports natural gas fracking might be bubbleEnvironmentalists and local residents have been casting the stinkeye on the pollution caused by natural gas fracking for a number of years, but the issue hasn’t gained much traction. The sticking point, of course, is money: there is a huge amount of it to be made from exploiting newly discovered natural gas deposits, particularly in the Marcellus shale formation that extends through New York, Pennsylvania, and down into the Appalachian states…or could the Marcellus and other fracking hotspots turn out to be the next big Ponzi scheme?

The Case for Fracking

Until now, the case for fracking has been based largely on ignorance. Anecdotal evidence of drinking water pollution from fracking has been treated as just that – anecdotes – and there has been no systematic analysis of the potential impacts on U.S. water supplies, mainly because the industry gained a series of exemptions from the Clean Water Act and other regulations that would have required disclosure of the chemicals used in fracking brine. That is all beginning to change. Under the Obama Administration, the EPA has set the wheels in motion for disclosure, and earlier this year the minority party in Congress issued a report on fracking brine based on available data.

The New York Times Gets Cracking on Fracking

Just a few months ago, an op-ed in The New York Times touted natural gas fracking as the greatest thing since sliced bread, but over on the reporting end there has been some great coverage of the downside. Water pollution is one major concern (fracking involves pumping chemical brine underground to jar natural gas out of shale formations). The Times also recently covered a report from Cornell University, which revealed that fracking releases copious amounts of methane gas into the atmosphere, making it worse than coal in terms of greenhouse gas emissions.

Follow the Money

The latest report from The Times cuts to the heart of the matter: the money. Times writer Ian Urbina got his hands on hundreds of industry emails and documents related to fracking that question “whether companies are intentionally, and even illegally, overstating the productivity of their wells,” raising serious questions about the industry’s long term profitability – unless of course, we taxpayers make up the difference with an increase in federal and state subsidies.

Canary in the Fracking Coal Mine

Aside from the issue of gas well productivity, which Urbina covers in detail, here’s just one small indicator of how much help the fracking industry is going to need: road repair. In Pennsylvania alone, the industry has had to pay more than $411 million since 2008 to repair the damage caused by thousands of trucks hauling fracking brine, wastewater, and equipment. Not all of the repairs have been up to snuff (to say nothing of repair-related inconveniences that impact local economies), and in some cases operators have had their permits revoked. Last year the state estimated that its taxpayers were still on the hook for about $35 million in repairs that could not be recovered from fracking companies. That could be the tip of the iceberg, so hold on to your hats. The industry’s “Enron moment,” as Urbina reports, could be just around the corner.

Image: Natural gas by D.H. Parks on 
Get CleanTechnica’s 1st (completely free) electric car report → “Electric Cars: What Early Adopters & First Followers Want.”
Keep up to date with all the hottest cleantech news by subscribing to our (free) cleantech newsletter, or keep an eye on sector-specific news by getting our (also free) solar energy newsletter, electric vehicle newsletter, or wind energy newsletter.


Tags: , , , ,

About the Author

specializes in military and corporate sustainability, advanced technology, emerging materials, biofuels, and water and wastewater issues. Tina’s articles are reposted frequently on Reuters, Scientific American, and many other sites. Views expressed are her own. Follow her on Twitter @TinaMCasey and Google+.

  • Oboebbr

    Well, evidently its profitable in a Ponzi-scheme kind of way…

  • @Reggie Jess
    It’s probably only profitable if you can avoid paying ALL the costs…

  • Reggie Jess

    If you ever spent time on wall street you would cast a very wary eye upon this kind of reporting…wall street says what is best for wall street at the moment, and you have to be aware of that. Exxon would not invest 40-50 billion in an unprofitable venture. Who do you think knows the situation better?

Back to Top ↑
  • Advertisements

  • Top Posts & Pages

  • Cool Cleantech Events

    Low Voltage Electrification Event, April 25-27. Detroit, Michigan (US)
    Delve deep into the benefits and challenges associated with EV power supply.

    Offshore Wind Market Development USA, May 11-12, Boston, Massachusetts (US)
    Network and establish your business in one of North America’s largest energy industries.

    Energy Storage USA, June 15-16, San Diego, California (US)
    Only event in the United States focused exclusively on the commercialization of storage.

    More details are on: Cleantech Events.

  • Advertisement

  • CleanTechnica Electric Car Report

    Electric Cars Early Adopters First Followers
  • Tesla Model 3 Review by EVANNEX

    Tesla Model 3 Review from EVANNEX
  • Tesla Model 3 Exclusive Video

    Tesla Model 3 Video
  • Tesla Model 3 Exclusive Pictures

    Tesla Model 3 Video
  • Tesla Model X Review #1 (Video)

    Tesla Model X Review from new owners Zach Shahan
  • Tesla Model X Review #2 (Pictures)

    Tesla Model X Review from Kyle Field
  • Tesla Model S Long-Term Review

    Tesla Model S Long Term Review from Kyle Field
  • Nissan LEAF Long-Term Review

    Nissan LEAF Long Term Review from Cynthia Shahan
  • Interview with Michael Liebreich

    Interview with Michael Liebreich
  • Interview with Akon (Teslas & Solar)

    Interview with Akon Tesla Model S Tesla Model X Solar Power Africa
  • Interview with Dr Nawal Al-Hosany

    Interview with Dr Nawal Al-Hosany
  • Interview with Gro Brundtland

    Gro Brundtland
  • Interview with President of Iceland

    President of Iceland Ólafur Ragnar Grímsson
  • Interview with Nick Sampson

    Faraday Future VP Nick Sampson
  • Interview with Dipal Barua

    Dipal Barua 1st ZFEP WInner
  • Interview with Jonathon Porritt

    Jonathon Porritt
  • Interview with Clint Wilder

    Interview with Clint Wilder
  • Interviews with Solar Impulse Pilots

    Bertrand Piccard Andre Borschberg
  • Check out more CleanTechnica Videos.

  • Join The Solar Revolution!

    Edison-solar-energy solar-energy-spill-nice-day
  • Cost of Solar Panels

  • Search the IM Network