Nuclear Energy

Published on March 24th, 2015 | by Roy L Hales

3

CPUC To Review The $4.7 Billion San Onofre Settlement

March 24th, 2015 by  

California Assembly Committee on Utilities and Commerce Calls for Transparency

Originally Published on the ECOreport

The lives of more than 8 million Californians may have been put at risk, when the steam generators at San Onofre Nuclear Generating Station (SONGS) malfunctioned. The subsequent California Public Utilities Commission (CPUC) investigation failed to probe into the extent to which Southern California Edison (SCE) was responsible for the facilities “design errors.” Now the California Assembly Committee on Utilities and Commerce is calling on the CPUC to review the $4.7 Billion San Onofre settlement.

Screenshot-2015-03-21-09.12.04-1038x499

“Anything short of total transparency will be viewed by the public, this committee and history as a complete failure to meet the duties of the commission,” wrote Assemblyman Anthony Rendon, Chair of the committee.

He informed the commission’s new president, Michael Picker, that “your efforts to reform the commission and restore the public’s trust cannot be completed until the dark clouds of the SONGS settlement and the spectre of the process manipulation by your predecessor (Michael Peevey) are fully and completely removed.”

Rendon012715

Mike Aguirre, an attorney representing San Diego’s ratepayers, has long been questioning the process that led to a $4.7 billion settlement with the nuclear facility’s owners.

Southern California Edison holds 78.2% ownership in the plant. Lesser partners are San Diego Gas & Electric Company (20%) and the City of Riverside Utilities Department (1.8%).

Prior to joining the commission in 2002, Peevey was the President of Southern California Edison.

During his May 14 summary, Aguirre told the commission their representation of “investigation into the reasonableness of Southern California Edison’s deployment of the defective steam generators was a promise of an investigation with the intent not to perform it.”

Peevey resigned in December, after a series of emails between his chief of staff and Pacific Gas & Electric (PG&E) led to concerns that the commission was too cozy with the utilities it was supposedly regulating.

Now it has been revealed that months prior to the “investigation,” Peevey met with Southern California Edison General Counsel to predetermine the outcome.

Screenshot-2015-01-20-14.42.19-892x576-1038x576-1038x576

Picker, his successor as President, recently admitted the commission has:

…faced real crises in the last few years, from the tragic PG&E gas transmission pipeline rupture in San Bruno that led to the discovery that our safety oversight was severely lacking, to the uncertainty both in the public, and inside the Commission, whether we are fair and even-handed in our actions.

The most obvious examples are a series of emails that show easy access to CPUC decision makers by utilities and other interested parties. They are troubling and very painful to read. But they are being carefully looked at by federal and state investigations, in which we are fully cooperating.

Whatever comes out of those investigations, the emails are signs to California citizens, to our stakeholders, and to ourselves, that we may not be ensuring equal access to our decisions and to our decision makers for everyone – our core value of fairness.

What I can do as President is to make sure that does not happen again.

Screenshot-2015-03-21-09.06.03

“I am encouraged that PUC President Michael Picker provided assurances that he is committed to making improvements to procedures and processes to modernize the Commission and improve transparency,” said Rendon, in a public statement.

“On a nearly daily basis we hear about new allegations if backroom deals and policies, procedures and an organizational culture at the PUC that continues to undermine the public’s confidence and trust in the committee,” he continued.

“Particularly troubling are the special rules in effect at the CPUC that discourage transparency. For example:

  • “The PUC allows ex parte contacts – making California one of only three sates nationwide that allows ex parte contact.
  • “The state Administrative Procedure Act does not apply to PUC and the appellate courts can decide if they want to hear a challenge to your decisions
  • “Regulated entities enjoy a presumption of confidentiality for their information.”

“Hopefully, this is the beginning of a complete overhaul of the culture at the CPUC and a set of reforms to set it on a better course,” said Ray Lutz of Citizens Oversight. “With a new CPUC president in place and this strong action by the State Assembly Cte, we can see a light at the end of a very long tunnel, but a light nonetheless. I attended the hearing and was impressed by the serious tone of the committee.”

Screenshot-2015-03-21-09.19.36
Image Credits: “San Onofre Nuclear Generating Station, Near San Clemente, California” by Ken Lund via Flickr (CC BY SA, 2.0 License); Assemblyman Anthony Rendon; Cropped picture of President Michael Picker (CPUC); Michael Peevey, President, California Public Utilities Commission (right) is interviewed by Rebecca Smith, Reporter, The Wall Street Journal from Dow JOnes Events, via Flickr (CC BY SA, 2.0 License); San Onofre Nuclear Generating Station, Near San Clemente, California by Ken Lund via Flickr (CC BY SA, 2.0 License)





Check out our new 93-page EV report, based on over 2,000 surveys collected from EV drivers in 49 of 50 US states, 26 European countries, and 9 Canadian provinces.

Tags: , , , , , , , , , , ,


About the Author

is the President of Cortes Community Radio , CKTZ 89.5 FM, where he has hosted a half hour program since 2014, and editor of the the ECOreport, a website dedicated to exploring how our lifestyle choices and technologies affect the West Coast of North America. He writes for both writes for both Clean Technica and PlanetSave on Important Media. He is a research junkie who has written over 1,600 since he was first published in 1982. Roy lives on Cortes Island, BC, Canada.



  • Ivor O’Connor
  • Matt

    Fox guarding the hen house. “Prior to joining the commission in 2002, Peevey was the President of Southern California Edison.” Fairly standard for utility commission (watch dogs, regulators, rate setters) to come from utilities. Guess who they are watch out for.

    • GCO

      And such ties ultimately led to Peevey’s departure.
      Things are moving in the right direction.

Back to Top ↑