Green Economy

Published on March 10th, 2012 | by Andrew


Milwaukee Solar PV Manufacturer Comes Out Publicly in Support of CASM Trade Case Against China

March 10th, 2012 by  

Photo courtesy: Helios Solar Works

Demand was initially brisk for the high-end monocrystalline silicon solar photovoltaic (PV) panels manufactured by Helios Solar Works at a new, highly automated 50-MW capacity factory on a brownfield industrial site Milwaukee’s city leaders designated for redevelopment and growth. That is until last summer, when founder Steven Ostrenga began noticing “a deep dive in [solar panel] pricing coming out of China that we just couldn’t meet.”

Helios’ silicon solar PV manufacturing business got off to a good start, and the company added a second shift, bringing its workforce to 34 as of last summer. That’s when heavily subsidized imports from China really began surging into the US market, bringing prices below Helios’ cost of production, as well as the cost of production in China, Helios and fellow Coalition for American Solar Manufacturing (CASM) members assert in anti-dumping and unfair trade petitions filed with the US Commerce Dept. and International Trade Commission.

Surging Chinese Silicon PV Imports; Unfair Trade

Competition is fine and good; it’s a prerequisite for a healthy, market-based capitalist system, but China’s been flaunting agreed-upon international trade rules established by the World Trade Organization (WTO), harming competitors in the US and other WTO member countries, Helios and CASM assert.

“We have a very high-end, efficient product, and we were priced, we believed, competitively. We have an automated facility and a good product priced competitively. Then starting in the summer last year, there was a deep dive in pricing [of silicon solar PV panels] coming out of China that we just couldn’t meet. It’s below their cost [of production], I believe, certainly our cost,” Ostrenga told Clean Technica.

Taken alone, Helios’ expansion doesn’t seem like much. However, solar and renewable energy will be key drivers for economic and jobs growth for decades to come, offering the US a chance to build a distributed clean energy infrastructure and re-establish a manufacturing base that has been on the wane for decades.

“We’re an automated manufacturer. We’ve hired across the jobs spectrum– MBAs and electrical engineers, accountants, people with technical degrees and skills and high school grads,” Ostrenga pointed out, “a lot of direct labor positions, which is a good fit in Wisconsin.

Some 23% of all jobs in Wisconsin are tied to manufacturing, he noted. “People with technical, high school degrees are looking for jobs, and we fill that need. We provide health benefits and we believe we provide livable, full-benefit wages and salaries that people can live on.”

Helios Solar Works isn’t alone. It’s among a dozen US solar PV manufacturers “that have been forced to downsize as a result of dumped and subsidized Chinese imports of solar cells and modules,” according to a CASM press release.

“At a micro level, I can speak for Helios. We’re not on plan. We’re operating just one shift now, and we prefer to be operating on two. There’s still a lot of product out there on the market from China,” Ostrenga said in the interview, noting that in July 2011 alone, US imports of Chinese silicon solar PV cells and modules exceeded that for all of 2010.

Surging US imports of Chinese silicon solar cells and modules in 2011 resulted in an abrupt reversal of what had been one of the rare instances of a US trade surplus with China. The US balance of trade in the solar PV sector as a whole was a negative $1.635 billion in 2011. That compares to a surplus of between $247 million and $539 million in 2010.

The spike in Chinese silicon PV exports to the US, Ostrenga and CASM believe, came in anticipation of CASM filing dumping and countervailing duty (CVD) petitions with the Commerce Dept. and ITC in order to avoid the tariffs that might be imposed.

As it turns out, that’s looks very likely. Having initially found in favor of CASM’s petitions, a Commerce Dept. ruling on the imposition of countervailing duties is expected to be made public March 20. A Commerce Dept. ruling on Chinese dumping of silicon solar PV in the US is going to be delayed until May, according to an unofficial notice CASM’s legal team at Wiley, Rein recently received from the Commerce Dept.

Establishing a Healthy, Sustainable Market for Solar Power

The precipitous decline in solar PV prices has been benefiting buyers and solar energy systems developers and integrators…over the short term, according to Ostrenga and CASM. The extraordinary fall in prices has been moving up the supply chain and is putting pressure on suppliers of mono and polycrystalline silicon, the raw material from which silicon solar PV cells and panels are made.

“Polysilicon is as low as $20 per kilogram,” Ostrenga told Clean Technica. Speaking to polysilicon producers, “some of them say that’s unsustainable, so it’s creeping up the supply chain. We have to have some margin out there. Right now, the cost [of silicon solar PV panels] at a modern factory gate is $1.00-$1.25 per Watt, depending on the type of module.”

At the end of the day, Helios Solar Works isn’t shying away from competition. “We’ve invested in a modern manufacturing facility and we want to add capacity and hire people.

“What we want is a fair playing field. What that does is foster a competitive industry. Prices will continue to decline and you’ll have healthier companies out there, a more stable industry that can support the warranties on these products.

“Look at Chinese firms like Yingli— it’s just not sustainable,” Ostrenga said. “If you’re an integrator, it’s great, but longer term, it’s preferable to have more and healthier suppliers out there for a healthy growing industry.”

The imposition of tariffs on Chinese silicon solar PV imports isn’t stopping the Chinese export juggernaut, nor is it preventing China’s biggest solar PV manufacturers to cut back on production. In fact, some are pressing their advantage and announced that they will be boosting production further in 2012.

In its recently announced 12th Five-Year Plan for the economy, China’s Ministry of Industry and Information is mandating that Chinese solar PV manufacturers significantly increase production and produce 5 gigawatts (GW) worth of solar PV modules by 2015 in order to bring their cost down to 0.8 yuan ($0.12) per kilowatt-hour (kWh).

It’s hoped that the Chinese government’s plans to spur domestic demand will take up much of the increased production, but China’s been saying it would do that for years now. Nonetheless, more than 90% of Chinese solar PV is being exported, offering little or no solace for US and other foreign competitors or improving prospects for a growing US solar PV manufacturing base and solar energy industry manufacturing jobs.

Check out our new 93-page EV report, based on over 2,000 surveys collected from EV drivers in 49 of 50 US states, 26 European countries, and 9 Canadian provinces.

Tags: , , , , , , , , , , , ,

About the Author

I've been reporting and writing on a wide range of topics at the nexus of economics, technology, ecology/environment and society for some five years now. Whether in Asia-Pacific, Europe, the Americas, Africa or the Middle East, issues related to these broad topical areas pose tremendous opportunities, as well as challenges, and define the quality of our lives, as well as our relationship to the natural environment.

  • PV-installer-gone fishing!

    In 1980, after a great start in reaction to the energy crisis of the 1970s, the U.S. all but turned its back on the solar industry. An industry that we created, then abandoned. Ronald Reagan, the worshiped hero of conservative Republicans, took the solar panels off the white house and slashed funding of research into solar energy.

    As Denis Hayes, former head of the Solar Energy Research Center (now known as NREL) puts it, “The tragedy is that the U.S. dropped the torch. The flame was kept alive by Japan and then Germany with their feed-in-tariffs. A dozen other countries now have worked to achieve the volume we needed to drive us down the cost curves. The basic technology of what we do now was all within our grasp in the Carter years.”

    And so now, with the anniversary of the Telstar, we cry that we want it all back? Just think of where we’d be today if we had LED the industry for the past 40 years. Good ole’ American innovation could have not only dominated solar, but led to drastic cost reductions paving the way to NATIONAL SECURITY and energy independence.

    Instead, the fossil fuel domination has led to brownfields, global oppression and environmental terrorism from Ecuador to Nigeria to New Orleans… And now Pennsylvania, Texas, and New York with documented health and water catastrophes thanks to fracking. Don’t forget three costly and tragic wars (don’t forget, the first thing Karzai did when put in as the puppet leader of Afghanistan was to sign off on the oil pipeline from Kazakhstan to the Persian Gulf, and its almost finished! Then we’ll come home…).

    I am all for American Jobs, don’t get me wrong. I am just shocked and disgusted that we are now crying “Foul!” against the Chinese as though there is really anything that is truly “made in America” anymore. We ceded the manufacturing mantle decades ago.

    to my solar comrades, this ruling has the “Abundant” natural gas guys laughing all the way to the bank!

  • Sww1120

    We need a comprehensive energy policy that includes protection for USA jobs. The political drumbeat of 2012 is jobs, jobs, jobs. Well that sucking sound you hear is US energy jobs being vacuumed up by the Chinese government subsidized energy sector. Time to take a stand for the USA

    • Bob_Wallace

      Big opportunity to do something about that at hand.

      It’s the election season. Get busy and help elect Congress Members who put America first. Help get rid of those who work for the fossil fuel industry.

      And help return President Obama to office so that new US energy job legislation gets signed.

Back to Top ↑